Evergreen Youth Secrets
  • Health News
  • Health Care
  • Staying Healthy
  • Beauty Advices
  • Health News
  • Health Care
  • Staying Healthy
  • Beauty Advices
No Result
View All Result
Evergreen Youth Secrets
No Result
View All Result
Home Health Care

Supreme Court confronts South Carolina bid to defund Planned Parenthood

by
April 2, 2025
in Health Care
0
Supreme Court confronts South Carolina bid to defund Planned Parenthood

The Supreme Court on Wednesday grappled with a case testing whether South Carolina was legally allowed to cut off Medicaid funding for Planned Parenthood. 

South Carolina restricted Planned Parenthood from participating in Medicaid because the organization provides abortions.  

However, the lawsuit was not about abortion access, but whether a Medicaid beneficiary has the “right” to pick their preferred health provider and sue if they can’t.  

The state, backed by the Trump administration, argued there was no such right. 

Conservative justices seemed sympathetic to concerns raised by the state about a constant flood of lawsuits if patients were allowed to sue over their provider being removed from Medicaid. 

“We’re talking about 9,000 providers who have been disqualified across the country, any one of whom, if you rule in favor of Respondents, can recruit a beneficiary and go to federal court and then line their pockets with the attorneys’ fees,” argued John Bursch, a lawyer with conservative legal group Alliance Defending Freedom, who was representing South Carolina. 

Liberal justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson suggested Congress clearly created a “right” for patients to choose any qualified provider they want, even if the Medicaid law doesn’t explicitly use the word. 

“The state knows it has an obligation … and the state knows the content of that obligation, which is that every individual has a right to choose their doctor,” Kagan said. 

The law says that “any individual” insured through Medicaid “may obtain” care from any qualified and willing provider.  

The justices noted that if patients don’t have the power to sue over their preferred provider, states could act as gatekeepers and defund providers for any arbitrary reason. 

“It would be people who provide abortion, people who don’t provide abortions … people who do gender transition treatment. Every state could split up the world by providers like that,” Kagan said. “That does not seem what this statute is all about.” 

Justice Amy Coney Barrett wondered if patients should be able to sue if their preferred provider was removed from Medicaid for malpractice complaints.  

“Does it make sense in that circumstance for Congress to have wanted plaintiffs to have a right to come in and sue?” she said. 

Attorneys for Planned Parenthood South Atlantic argued Congress wanted to protect the “intensely personal right” of a patient to choose a doctor.  

“There aren’t many things that are more important than being able to choose your doctor, the person that you see when you’re at your most vulnerable, facing some of the most significant challenges to your life and your health,” Nicole Sharsky argued for the organization. 

The lawsuit comes as red states across the country are looking for ways to deprive Planned Parenthood of funding. Nationally, the Trump administration recently said it will withhold federal family planning grants from nine Planned Parenthood affiliates.  

Medicaid is prohibited from paying for almost all abortions, but states want to cut government funding for other services it provides as well. 

South Carolina said the money Planned Parenthood receives for providing other health services-— like cancer screenings, birth control, physical exams and more — “frees up their other funds to provide more abortions.” 

Three other states — Texas, Arkansas and Missouri — already block Planned Parenthood from seeing Medicaid patients and the organization has said it expects many other Republican-led states to do the same if the Supreme Court sides with South Carolina. 

A decision is expected later this summer.

Previous Post

HHS fires entire staff of program that helps low-income people afford heat and air conditioning

Next Post

Record high can’t afford health care: Gallup

Next Post
Record high can’t afford health care: Gallup

Record high can't afford health care: Gallup

Stay updated with the latest news, exclusive offers, and special promotions. Sign up now and be the first to know! As a member, you'll receive curated content, insider tips, and invitations to exclusive events. Don't miss out on being part of something special.

    Popular News

    Trump stokes fear, confusion with pulled emergency abortion guidance

    Trump stokes fear, confusion with pulled emergency abortion guidance

    June 7, 2025
    Drinking sugar may be worse than eating it, study finds

    Drinking sugar may be worse than eating it, study finds

    June 7, 2025
    A West Virginia prosecutor is warning women that a miscarriage could lead to criminal charges

    A West Virginia prosecutor is warning women that a miscarriage could lead to criminal charges

    June 6, 2025

    Trending

    Trump says abortions not ‘big factor’ in elections anymore

    Trump says abortions not ‘big factor’ in elections anymore

    August 8, 2024
    The end of a shortage of popular weight-loss drugs may mean many people lose access to them

    The end of a shortage of popular weight-loss drugs may mean many people lose access to them

    October 9, 2024
    Killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO prompts flurry of stories on social media over denied insurance claims

    Killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO prompts flurry of stories on social media over denied insurance claims

    December 6, 2024
    Most women oppose leaving abortion laws to the states, across party lines: poll

    Most women oppose leaving abortion laws to the states, across party lines: poll

    August 14, 2024

    Recent News

    Trump stokes fear, confusion with pulled emergency abortion guidance

    Trump stokes fear, confusion with pulled emergency abortion guidance

    June 7, 2025
    Drinking sugar may be worse than eating it, study finds

    Drinking sugar may be worse than eating it, study finds

    June 7, 2025

    Popular News

    • Trump stokes fear, confusion with pulled emergency abortion guidance
    • Drinking sugar may be worse than eating it, study finds

    About Evergreen Youth Secrets

    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Email Whitelisting

    Copyright © 2025 Evergreenyouthsecrets.com. All Rights Reserved.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Health News
    • Health Care
    • Staying Healthy
    • Beauty Advices

    Copyright © 2025 Evergreenyouthsecrets.com. All Rights Reserved.